Nerdy Prudes Must Die

Will Branner

Max Jägerman

Mariah Rose Faith Casillas

Stephanie Lauter/Caitlyn

Bryce Charles

Detective Shapiro/Brenda/PJ/Reporter

Corey Dorris

Mayor Solomon Lauter/Jason Jepson/Pokotho/Cop

Angela Giarratana

Grace Chasity/Drama Student

Lauren Lopez

Ruth Fleming/Donna Daggit/Emma Perkins/Bliklotep/Brooke

Jon Matteson

Richie Lipschitz/Boy Jerry/Trevor/Paul Matthews/Wiggog Y'Wrath/Student

Curt Mega

Officer Bailey/Mark Chasity/Kyle Clauger/T'noy Karaxis/News Announcer

Joey Richter

Peter Spankoffski/Dan Reynolds/Drama Student

Kim Whalen

Miss Mulberry/Karen Chasity/Reese/Miss Tessburger/Stacy/Nibblenephim

Hamilton Davis Weaver

Cop/Reporter/Student

Virginia Vass

Reporter/Student